Kibana Flyout Overlap: A Deep Dive Into Inspector Panel Issues

Hey guys! Ever been frustrated when working in Kibana, and flyouts start overlapping, making it a total mess to navigate? Specifically, the Inspector panel has been giving some folks a headache. Let's dive deep into this issue, how it's happening, and some potential fixes. We'll break down the core problems and what we can do to solve them. This is super important, because a clean UI makes all the difference when you're trying to analyze data and make sense of everything.

The Core Problem: Flyout Overlap in Kibana

So, the main issue is that flyouts, especially within the Inspector panel of Kibana, are prone to overlapping. The Inspector panel is super important for debugging and understanding what's going on behind the scenes with your visualizations and data. The problem arises because of how these flyouts are managed and how they interact with each other, leading to a cluttered and confusing interface. This directly impacts user experience, making it harder to access the information needed and slowing down the entire analysis process. We’re talking about things like the “Metric details flyout” or the “document flyout” getting in the way, obscuring crucial information. Understanding the architecture of Kibana and how different components interact is key to solving this. This is not just a visual issue; it impacts productivity and overall workflow efficiency. The overlap makes it harder to quickly see the metrics and details you need, especially when you are in a hurry. Dealing with the flyout overlap is something that the team at Elastic is working on, and we'll explore some of the solutions and approaches that they're considering. When you're in the middle of analyzing data, every second counts, and a smooth, uncluttered interface makes all the difference. We need to think about how these elements are displayed and handled. The core of the problem lies in the way these flyouts are managed and the lack of a consistent system to control their opening and closing behaviors. Without a unified approach, flyouts can easily become a jumbled mess, and that’s precisely what we’re trying to avoid.

Why Overlapping Happens: The Technical Breakdown

Okay, let’s get into the nitty-gritty. The Inspector panel uses openLazyFlyout to handle some flyouts, but not all of them. The core overlays in Kibana are supposed to manage the opening and closing of flyouts, ensuring a clean interface. However, not all flyouts, like the ones for metric details or documents, are using these core overlays. This is where the trouble starts, because the flyouts don’t close when you open another one. The openLazyFlyout method was attempted as a fix for the metric details flyout overlap, but it didn't solve the problem. It’s a bit like trying to herd cats – each flyout has its own behavior, and there isn't a central control to keep them in order. The fact that some flyouts use core overlays while others don't creates an inconsistency. This inconsistency is the root cause of the overlap. Think of it like this: some flyouts follow the rules, while others are doing their own thing, and the result is a mess. This highlights the need for a unified system. We need to make sure all flyouts behave in a consistent manner. One of the goals here is to ensure that all flyouts use the same management system to eliminate the inconsistent behavior. This will lead to a much better user experience.

Circular Dependencies and the Create Alert Flyout

Now, let’s look at another specific issue: the Create alert flyout. Discover has a tool called dismissFlyouts, which is great for managing flyouts, but it can't be used in the Inspector panel due to circular dependencies. Circular dependencies mean that different parts of the system are relying on each other in a way that causes conflicts, making it difficult to fix problems. This is one of the reasons why fixing the overlap issue is so tricky. It's not just a matter of applying a quick fix; it requires understanding the dependencies between different parts of the Kibana application. This problem is more about architecture than just aesthetics. Circular dependencies can make your code fragile and hard to maintain. They make it difficult to isolate and fix the issue. Dealing with this is a common challenge in software development, and Kibana is not immune to this problem. The team at Elastic has to consider all these issues. Working through those types of problems demands careful planning and execution.

Partial Fixes and Ongoing Efforts

Good news, guys! A partial fix has been implemented. A fix has been put in place to prevent the metric details flyout and the Inspect flyout from overlapping. While it's not a complete solution, it’s a step in the right direction. It shows that the developers are actively working on the problem and trying to improve the user experience. The fix is at here. This shows that the team is trying to be proactive with the issues that are impacting the user interface. It addresses a specific instance of the overlap problem, which is a great start. These kinds of changes, while not always perfect, are the bread and butter of software development. They incrementally improve the product and make it better for users. Even small improvements make a big difference, and that's especially true when it comes to user interface design. These incremental improvements build upon each other, making the experience better. So, kudos to the team for taking the initiative and trying to make a difference! Even if it's just a partial fix, it's a sign that they're paying attention. It's all about making the interface more efficient and less confusing.

Future Solutions: What's Next?

So, what's next? There are several avenues being explored to find a more consistent fix:

• Enhancing the Lens Component: One idea is to enhance the Lens component to accept extra click actions. This would allow the consumer to handle actions, giving developers more control over what happens when flyouts open and close. This is an example of a good architecture. By providing more flexibility, you allow developers to handle the nuances of different use cases more effectively. The goal is to make it easier to manage the flyout behaviors. This means improving the way these elements are managed, not just how they look. The team is looking at the best ways to extend the Lens component so that the user can have maximum control of their visual experience.
• Using core.overlays for All Flyouts: A more unified approach would be to render all flyouts using core.overlays. This would provide a consistent way of managing the flyouts. This approach should provide a way to streamline the management of flyouts. It would help to provide a consistent experience across Kibana. This could solve a bunch of the issues since all flyouts would be managed the same way.
• Exploring EUI's Flyout Management: The new flyout management system from EUI (Elastic UI Framework) could potentially help. EUI is a collection of React UI components that are used in Elastic products. If the new flyout management in EUI can be leveraged, it could provide a more robust and standardized solution. Using components like this could provide a more consistent experience. This is one of the benefits of using a robust UI framework, because these frameworks provide well-tested, production-ready components. This also promotes consistency across the user interface. This is especially valuable in a large application like Kibana. The adoption of EUI could streamline the development process and reduce the amount of custom code needed. It's something to be strongly considered. Using external and trusted frameworks provides a solid base for a UI.

Conclusion

Fixing flyout overlap is a complex task, but the Elastic team is actively working on it. It involves identifying the root causes, implementing partial fixes, and exploring long-term solutions. Improving the UI and user experience is the ultimate goal. By understanding the technical details and the ongoing efforts, we can stay informed and appreciate the work that goes into improving Kibana. It's a testament to the team's dedication to creating a great product. The flyout overlap issue is one small piece of the puzzle. By improving the user experience, you’re making the whole product better. Let's hope these efforts result in a much smoother and more intuitive user interface!

If you want to know more about this, you can visit the Elastic's official website. It's a great resource for staying up-to-date on Kibana and Elastic's products. You can find all the details on the ongoing improvements to their product.

Elastic